The federal regulator is now pushing on two fronts. On October 9 the CFTC announced two rules on what counts as a “swap”: an interim final rule, in force since October 19, that takes bets placed with state- or tribally-licensed sportsbooks and casinos out of the definition, and a proposal to write event contracts, sports included, into it. Comments on both close November 18. Neither is the revised Rule 40.11, which governs which event contracts exchanges may list; that rule is still a proposal. Then on November 5 the Commission issued an interpretation saying its impartial-access rule generally bars exchanges from limiting access by a trader’s location within the United States, and gave them 30 days to drop state-by-state restrictions or explain why they cannot. It is guidance. It was published in the Federal Register and took effect on November 10, and it does not address the court orders that require some platforms to geofence.

Utah is the sharpest new fight. Its Attorney General sued Kalshi and the trading firm Susquehanna in state court on October 20; the United States and the CFTC sued Utah on October 26, the federal government’s tenth action against a state; and on October 28 the Attorney General’s Office filed criminal charges against Kalshi, naming co-founders Tarek Mansour and Luana Lopes Lara as co-defendants, with Kalshi’s initial appearance set for December 4. Crypto.com’s exchange also sued Utah’s Attorney General; on November 12 Judge Shelby consolidated that suit into the federal case, and the federal government’s and the exchange’s requests for a temporary restraining order and preliminary injunction are both set for a hearing on November 20.

The circuits still stand two to one against the platforms, and the question is in front of the Supreme Court. The Third Circuit held in April 2026 that Kalshi’s sports event contracts are likely “swaps” whose regulation Congress left to the CFTC. The Ninth Circuit disagreed on August 28 (KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad) and on November 4 denied rehearing, with no judge calling for an en banc vote, which leaves Kalshi until about February 2027 to petition the Supreme Court. On November 9 Kalshi asked the Ninth Circuit to stay its mandate while it petitions. On September 25 the Sixth Circuit ruled for Ohio and Tennessee; Kalshi’s petition to the full court is pending, Tennessee filed its response on November 10, Ohio’s was due November 12 and is not yet on the free public record, and until the court rules the injunction Tennessee’s federal court granted Kalshi stays in place. Three cert petitions are waiting on responses: New Jersey’s (No. 26-299; Kalshi’s response is now due December 7), Robinhood’s (No. 26-338) and Crypto.com’s (No. 26-344); Nevada’s responses to those two are now due December 7 as well. The whole arc is on the path to the Supreme Court.

The two losses are not the same loss. The Ninth Circuit agreed with the Third that the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state regulation of futures trading, and split only on whether sports contracts are the kind of instrument the Act covers. The Sixth Circuit went further: it held that even if the contracts were swaps, the Act would not preempt state gambling law at all. All three are preliminary-injunction decisions rather than final judgments. The one final merits ruling so far came from a federal judge in Utah, now on appeal to the Tenth Circuit, where 37 states have filed an amicus brief on Utah’s side.

The district courts are not lined up behind the circuits, and the interim rulings keep splitting. On October 30 a federal judge in Illinois entered a preliminary injunction in all three Illinois cases that bars the State from enforcing its licensing law, fees, taxes and criminal provisions against swaps, sports contracts included, on CFTC-regulated exchanges and brokers; Illinois appealed to the Seventh Circuit the same day, where the Wisconsin appeals are fully briefed but for replies. According to the parties, the Seventh Circuit has consolidated Illinois’s three appeals and set its opening brief for December 14, and on November 12 every party asked the district court to pause the Illinois cases until the appeals are decided. On November 3 a Second Circuit panel went the other way on interim relief, denying Kalshi’s New York and Connecticut motions and Coinbase’s Connecticut motion for injunctions pending appeal without reaching the merits. On November 10 a second judge in the Southern District of New York, Colleen McMahon, denied Novig a preliminary injunction against New York on different reasoning from Judge Torres’s: where Judge Torres held that the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt the State’s gambling law, Judge McMahon concluded that Novig’s sports contracts are likely not “swaps” at all. Novig appealed the same day. On November 4 the First Circuit heard Robinhood’s Massachusetts appeal, which turns on ripeness rather than preemption, and Judge Corley granted the California tribes a preliminary injunction barring Kalshi’s sports contracts on their Indian lands. The Fourth Circuit still has not decided Maryland, argued in May.

The enforcement map keeps widening, and more platforms are suing first. After Ohio’s cease-and-desist deadline ran out, Polymarket US sued Ohio. All six recipients of Missouri’s letters have now sued the State: Novig and Crypto.com’s exchange on October 16, Kalshi on October 27, Underdog on November 8, and Robinhood and Polymarket US on November 9. That same day Missouri’s Attorney General answered Novig’s suit with counterclaims under the federal Unlawful Internet Gambling Enforcement Act and state consumer and nuisance law, the State’s first claims in court against a platform. On November 10 it agreed not to pursue Kalshi in state courts or agencies until a final judgment in Kalshi’s federal case or a non-voluntary dismissal of its state-law counterclaims there, and the next day it answered that case with counterclaims. No Missouri court has ruled. Robinhood agreed to stop new sports contracts in Ohio, and Polymarket US agreed to wind down its sports contracts in Michigan by November 25. Kalshi (October 23) and Polymarket US (October 27) sued Louisiana, the first cases here in the Fifth Circuit. On November 12 Louisiana’s Attorney General sued 31 companies, Kalshi and Polymarket US among them, in state court in Tangipahoa Parish, asking for a temporary restraining order, a preliminary injunction and civil penalties. Kalshi asked its federal court for a restraining order against the State the same day. The federal court had not ruled as of November 12, and whether the state court has acted is not confirmed. On November 4 Arkansas’s Attorney General sued Kalshi under the state’s consumer-protection law, and on November 9 Polymarket US and Crypto.com’s exchange sued Arkansas in federal court before it had acted against them. Two developments still cut the other way: Minnesota’s statutory ban on prediction-market platforms is preliminarily enjoined as to CFTC-registered exchanges, and North Carolina enacted a July 2026 law that recognizes the CFTC’s authority and taxes trading-fee revenue rather than banning the platforms.

Zoom into the docket list and it turns granular and contradictory: the same company can operate freely in one state, be blocked by a judge in the next, and face a fresh lawsuit in a third. Read this as a dated snapshot. Nearly every case below is preliminary and under appeal, and it changes week to week. This is informational, not legal advice; always verify a platform’s current, location-specific eligibility before relying on it.