Overview
The industry’s most consequential loss so far, and the direct counterweight to New Jersey. Judge Analisa Torres denied Kalshi a preliminary injunction and held that the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt New York’s gambling law, reasoning that the CEA preserves state authority over conduct within traditional police powers and that Congress did not clearly displace state gambling regulation. Kalshi appealed, and the Second Circuit docketed the appeal on July 8. Judge Torres denied an injunction pending appeal in July, and on November 3, 2026 a Second Circuit panel (Judges Walker, Jacobs and Bianco) denied one too, in a short order that also denied the Kalshi and Coinbase Connecticut motions and said only that the appellants had not made the required showing. That is not a merits ruling. The appeal itself is pending.
Timeline
Fall 2025
Kalshi sues the New York State Gaming Commission (1:25-cv-08846) seeking to block state enforcement.
April 2026
CFTC separately sues New York over its enforcement posture.
July 2026
Judge Torres denies the preliminary injunction; holds CEA does not preempt New York law. The Second Circuit dockets Kalshi’s appeal on July 8.
September 3, 2026
The Second Circuit orders this appeal heard in tandem with the Kalshi and Coinbase Connecticut appeals, one panel to decide all three injunction motions.
October 21, 2026
The Second Circuit sets argument on Kalshi’s motion for an injunction pending appeal for November 3, 2026.
November 3, 2026
After argument, the panel denies Kalshi’s motion for an injunction pending appeal in a single order that also denies the Kalshi and Coinbase Connecticut motions. The merits appeal continues.
What's next: The merits appeal continues, and nothing now bars New York from enforcing its gambling laws against Kalshi while it does. New York filed its appellee brief on October 30 (ECF 72), and the court granted the CFTC, an amicus, argument time the same day (ECF 70). Kalshi moved on November 5 to file an oversized brief (ECF 76); the motion was undecided as of November 9. Amicus briefs supporting New York followed on November 6 from the North American Gaming Regulators Association with the International Association of Gaming Regulators (ECF 83), Better Markets (ECF 84), Ohio and Nevada with 35 other states, the District of Columbia and the Northern Mariana Islands (ECF 91), former CFTC Chairman Gary Gensler (ECF 93) and the American Gaming Association (ECF 96), and on November 9 from the Indian Gaming Association, the National Congress of American Indians and other tribal organizations with 27 tribes (ECF 99). No merits argument date is set. In the district court, Kalshi’s request for a stay pending appeal and the State’s request for leave to move to dismiss are undecided. The CFTC separately sued New York, and the Gaming Commission has gone to state court to enforce its subpoenas to Kalshi. On November 10 another judge in the same district, Judge McMahon, denied Novig a preliminary injunction against New York on different reasoning (Ludlow Exchange, LLC v. James).
This page is informational, not legal advice. Nearly every entry in this tracker is a preliminary ruling under appeal. Always verify a platform's current, location-specific eligibility directly with the venue before relying on this page.