Are Prediction Markets Legal in New York?

Last updated November 12, 2026. Snapshot — not legal advice.

As of November 12, 2026, New York has a restriction on prediction-market platforms currently in effect.

Prediction markets in New York

Restriction in effect
New York is the sharpest federal-versus-state conflict in the country, and it now runs against several platforms at once. Against Kalshi there are three tracks: a federal judge denied it a preliminary injunction and held that the Commodity Exchange Act does not preempt New York’s gambling law (KalshiEX LLC v. Williams, July 2026, now on appeal to the Second Circuit) — the leading counterweight to New Jersey; the Attorney General separately brought a state-court special proceeding under Executive Law § 63(12); and the United States and the CFTC sued the state. The Attorney General also petitioned against Coinbase Financial Markets, which removed the case to federal court, where the contested question so far is which courthouse hears it at all. On September 24, 2026 she filed a matching petition against QCX LLC, which does business as Polymarket US, which removed it to federal court the same day and sued the state in return. Two more designated contract markets sued the state pre-emptively: Crypto.com’s exchange arm, whose injunction motion was argued in September 2026 alongside the federal government’s, and Novig, which lost its bid for a preliminary injunction on November 10, 2026, when Judge McMahon concluded that its sports contracts are likely not “swaps” under the Commodity Exchange Act at all; Novig has appealed. In October New York moved to send its Polymarket US petition back to state court, Polymarket US moved for a preliminary injunction in its own suit, and the Gaming Commission petitioned the state court to enforce its subpoenas to Kalshi (returnable December 14). On November 3, 2026 a Second Circuit panel denied Kalshi’s motion for an injunction pending appeal, without reaching the merits, so nothing bars New York from enforcing while the appeal runs; Kalshi has also asked the federal court to block an Attorney General investigative subpoena it says seeks discovery on the State’s petition, and in November the Attorney General went to state court to enforce that subpoena (returnable December 17). Meanwhile a state proceeding seeks to shut Kalshi down while the CFTC has ordered it to keep operating.

Litigation affecting New York

KalshiEX LLC v. WilliamsA Second Circuit panel denied Kalshi’s motion for an injunction pending appeal on November 3, 2026, without reaching the merits. Judge Torres had denied a preliminary injunction in July 2026, holding the CEA does not preempt New York gambling law.
Injunction denied; injunction pending appeal denied (2d Cir., Nov. 3); merits appeal pending
United States v. State of New YorkJudge Schofield heard the federal government’s preliminary-injunction motion on September 14, 2026, jointly with Crypto.com’s, and did not rule from the bench.
Preliminary injunction argued; decision pending
People of the State of New York v. KalshiEX LLCThe New York AG filed an Executive Law § 63(12) special proceeding against KalshiEX LLC seeking an injunction, restitution, disgorgement, and statutory penalties.
Removed; remand motion briefed and undecided
People of the State of New York v. Coinbase Financial Markets, Inc.Coinbase removed New York’s state-court enforcement petition to federal court (April 2026); the state’s remand motion has been fully briefed since June 2026 and is undecided.
Removed; remand motion briefed and undecided
People of the State of New York v. Gemini Titan, LLCGemini removed New York’s state-court enforcement action to federal court (April 2026); the state’s remand motion has been fully briefed since June 2026 and is undecided.
Removed; remand motion briefed and undecided
People of the State of New York v. QCX LLC (d/b/a Polymarket US)The New York Attorney General filed an Executive Law § 63(12) petition against Polymarket US and sought a restraining order; Polymarket US removed it before service, invoking the federal-officer removal statute.
Removed (Judge Abrams); remand opposition filed, reply due Nov. 16
Ludlow Exchange, LLC (Novig) v. JamesJudge McMahon denied Novig a preliminary injunction on November 10, 2026, concluding at this preliminary stage that its sports event contracts are not "swaps" under the Commodity Exchange Act, so New York may apply its gambling laws to them. Novig appealed the same day.
Preliminary injunction denied (Nov. 10, 2026); Novig has appealed to the Second Circuit
North American Derivatives Exchange, Inc. (Crypto.com) v. JamesJudge Schofield heard Crypto.com’s preliminary-injunction motion on September 14, 2026, jointly with the federal government’s parallel motion, and did not rule from the bench.
Preliminary injunction argued; decision pending
QCX LLC (d/b/a Polymarket US) v. JamesPolymarket US moved for a preliminary injunction against New York’s Attorney General and Gaming Commission (October 12, 2026), arguing the Commodity Exchange Act preempts state gambling law as applied to its exchange.
Preliminary-injunction motion filed; no ruling (Judge Abrams)
Matter of New York State Gaming Commission v. Kalshi, Inc. (subpoena enforcement)A state judge ordered Kalshi to show cause by December 14, 2026 why it should not be compelled to comply with the Gaming Commission’s July subpoenas.
Order to show cause signed; return date December 14, 2026
Matter of the Attorney General of the State of New York v. KalshiEX LLC (subpoena enforcement)New York’s Attorney General went to state court to compel Kalshi to comply with her September 25, 2026 investigative subpoena; the court set a December 17 return date.
Order to show cause signed; return date December 17, 2026

Which platforms are available in New York?

Each platform’s own published availability list, checked September 24, 2026. This table covers the platforms whose complete list we could verify from a primary source: Kalshi, Polymarket (international), DKeX (DraftKings Predictions), Underdog (Underdog Predict), Novig.

Platform availability in New York
PlatformStatus in New YorkSource
KalshiOffered here, per the platform’s own availability listPlatform’s list
Polymarket (international)Unavailable herePlatform’s list
DKeX (DraftKings Predictions)Offered, with sports restrictedPlatform’s list (archived Sep 16)
Underdog (Underdog Predict)Unavailable herePlatform’s list
NovigOffered here, per the platform’s own availability listPlatform’s list

Sports betting & gambling in New York

Legal — Online & Retail

Retail at commercial/tribal casinos from 2019; statewide mobile launched January 2022 The market is regulated by the New York State Gaming Commission. Tribal gaming: Moderate (Oneida, Seneca, and Akwesasne Mohawk compacts).

The federal-vs-state fight

Every entry in this fight turns on the same question: does a prediction-market platform's federal regulation by the CFTC preempt a state's gambling law, or does the state retain authority to restrict it? Courts around the country are answering that question differently — sometimes for the platform, sometimes for the state — and almost every ruling so far is preliminary and under appeal. Treat this page as a snapshot, not a final word.

This page is informational, not legal advice. Nearly every litigation entry referenced here is a preliminary ruling under appeal. Always verify a platform's current, location-specific eligibility directly with the venue before relying on this page.