Removed; remand motion briefed and undecided2d Cir.State v. Platform
Docket last checked November 11, 2026. Snapshot — not legal advice.
As of November 12, 2026, New York has a restriction on prediction-market platforms currently in effect. New York status and cases →
Overview
New York’s Attorney General brought a special proceeding under Executive Law § 63(12) — a petition, not a complaint — against KalshiEX LLC in state court (July 2026), making New York the only state litigating against the platform on three tracks at once alongside Kalshi v. Williams and the CFTC’s suit. The petition seeks a permanent injunction against unlicensed gambling, an accounting, restitution, disgorgement, and statutory penalties. Kalshi is the only respondent — unlike Baltimore’s actions, no brokerage distributors are named, and the Governor is not a petitioner despite a joint announcement. Note that the widely-reported "$36 billion" exposure figure does not appear in the petition; it is press arithmetic on the statutory penalty formula. This proceeding also sits in direct tension with a federal order directing the exchange to continue operating. (Caption, court, statute, and filing date confirmed verbatim against the filed petition PDF.)
Changes
October 2026
Filing
Kalshi asked Judge Broderick for a protective order against an Attorney General investigative subpoena it says seeks discovery on the pending case. The Attorney General says the subpoena belongs to a separate investigation into possible fraud and false advertising in the prediction-market industry. The remand motion is still undecided.
We said this case had been referred to Judge Torres. She declined it as unrelated on August 10 and it went to Judge Broderick. We had also omitted New York’s remand motion, fully briefed since August 28 and undecided.
The Attorney General files a verified petition against KalshiEX LLC under Executive Law § 63(12).
August 2026
The CFTC invokes emergency authority directing the exchange to maintain operations, in response to the state proceeding.
August 2026
New York moves to remand (August 7); Judge Torres declines the case as unrelated and it is reassigned to Judge Broderick (August 10); remand briefing closes August 28.
October 30, 2026
Kalshi asks the federal court for a protective order against an Attorney General investigative subpoena it says seeks discovery on this case. The Attorney General says the subpoena belongs to a separate fraud and false-advertising investigation.
November 2026
The Attorney General petitions the state court to compel Kalshi to comply with her September 25 investigative subpoena (Index No. 454828/2026); the court orders Kalshi to show cause on December 17.
What's next: Kalshi removed the proceeding from New York County Supreme Court on July 31, 2026. It was referred to Judge Torres as possibly related to Kalshi’s own suit (1:25-cv-08846); she declined it as unrelated on August 10, and it went to Judge Vernon S. Broderick. New York moved to remand on August 7; the motion has been fully briefed since August 28 and is undecided. A separate subpoena dispute has now reached Judge Broderick: in an October 30 joint letter, Kalshi asked for a protective order under Rule 26(c), or alternatively an All Writs Act order, barring the Attorney General from using an investigative subpoena from her Investor Protection Bureau (served July 31 and revised September 25) to get discovery on the claims in this case. The Attorney General says that subpoena belongs to a wholly unrelated investigation into potential fraud and false advertising by players in the prediction-market industry, including Kalshi, and that the court lacks jurisdiction, should abstain and faces an unripe request. Kalshi filed a further letter on November 4 about a development concerning the revised subpoena (its text is not on the free public record). The Attorney General has since gone to state court to enforce that subpoena: in New York County Supreme Court (Index No. 454828/2026) a judge signed an order directing Kalshi to show cause on December 17, 2026 why it should not be compelled to comply and pay a $50 statutory penalty. Judge Broderick has not ruled on remand or on Kalshi’s protective-order request. Separately, the Gaming Commission’s state-court petition to enforce its own July subpoenas is returnable December 14.
Parties
Plaintiffs
People of the State of New York, by Letitia James, Attorney General
Defendants
KalshiEX LLC
This page is informational, not legal advice. Nearly every entry in this tracker is a preliminary ruling under appeal. Always verify a platform's current, location-specific eligibility directly with the venue before relying on this page.