Overview
The Attorney General’s second front against Kalshi in state court. In November 2026 her office petitioned the state supreme court in Manhattan to compel Kalshi to comply with an investigative subpoena duces tecum dated and served September 25, 2026. Under CPLR § 2308(b) it asks for an order requiring Kalshi to produce all responsive, non-privileged documents within 10 days and to pay a $50 statutory penalty. The court signed an order directing Kalshi to show cause on December 17, 2026, with Kalshi’s opposition due December 3.
This is a fight over a subpoena, not a ruling on whether Kalshi broke any law. The Attorney General has told the federal court that the subpoena belongs to an investigation into potential fraud and false advertising by players in the prediction-market industry, including Kalshi, which she says is unrelated to her gambling petition against Kalshi. Kalshi argues the subpoena is a way to get discovery on that petition and has asked the federal judge hearing it to block that use. The Gaming Commission is separately enforcing its own July subpoenas. (Index number, relief and dates read from the signed order to show cause. The caption page and the petition have not been read.)
Timeline
September 2026
The Attorney General serves a revised investigative subpoena on Kalshi (dated September 25), following one served July 31.
October 30, 2026
Kalshi asks the federal court in the Attorney General’s gambling case for a protective order against the subpoena; the Attorney General says it belongs to a separate fraud and false-advertising investigation.
November 2026
The Attorney General petitions the state court to compel compliance (Index No. 454828/2026); the court orders Kalshi to show cause on December 17.
What's next: Kalshi was to be served by November 13, its opposition is due December 3, and the return date is December 17, 2026. In the federal case over the Attorney General’s gambling petition, Kalshi’s request for a protective order against the same subpoena is pending before Judge Broderick. December 17, 2026: Return date on the order to show cause (Kalshi to show cause why it should not be compelled to comply)
Parties
Plaintiffs
- Office of the New York State Attorney General (Letitia James)
This page is informational, not legal advice. Nearly every entry in this tracker is a preliminary ruling under appeal. Always verify a platform's current, location-specific eligibility directly with the venue before relying on this page.