KalshiEX LLC v. Schuler (6th Cir., consolidated with the Tennessee appeal)

Also captioned KalshiEX LLC v. Orgel

States win: Ohio affirmed, Tennessee vacated (6th Cir.); en banc response ordered6th Cir.Kalshi v. State

Docket last checked November 12, 2026. Snapshot — not legal advice.

As of November 12, 2026, the legality of prediction markets in Tennessee is unresolved — litigation is ongoing with no final ruling yet. Tennessee status and cases →

As of November 12, 2026, Ohio has a restriction on prediction-market platforms currently in effect. Ohio status and cases →

Overview

The third federal appeals court to rule, and the second against the platforms. Kalshi sued both states pre-emptively. In Tennessee, Judge Aleta Trauger (M.D. Tenn.) granted it a preliminary injunction in February 2026, finding its sports event contracts likely "swaps"; in Ohio, Chief Judge Sarah Morrison (S.D. Ohio) denied one. The Sixth Circuit heard the two appeals together on July 30, 2026 (Clay, Gibbons and Bloomekatz, JJ.).

On September 25, 2026 it ruled for both states in a published opinion by Judge Gibbons, with no separate concurrence or dissent. It affirmed the Ohio denial, vacated the Tennessee injunction and remanded both. The holding has two independent parts. First, Kalshi “has not shown that its sports-event contracts satisfy the statutory definition of a ‘swap’” and so has not shown they fall within the CFTC’s exclusive jurisdiction. Second, “even assuming that Kalshi’s sports-event contracts are swaps,” the Commodity Exchange Act “neither expressly nor impliedly preempts Ohio’s or Tennessee’s gambling laws.”

That second holding is what sets it apart. The Ninth Circuit agreed with the Third that the Act preempts state regulation of futures trading and split only on whether sports contracts are covered; the Sixth Circuit held that even covered contracts would not displace state gambling law. It is binding on every federal court in Ohio, Tennessee, Michigan and Kentucky, including the three pending Michigan platform appeals. Like the others, it reviews preliminary-injunction rulings, not final judgments.

On October 9, 2026 Kalshi petitioned for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc in both appeals, arguing the decision conflicts with the Third and Ninth Circuits and with the Sixth Circuit’s own precedent, and that the CFTC’s October 9 rulemakings on the definition of “swap” warrant another look. The CFTC filed an amicus brief on October 16. On October 28 the court directed Ohio and Tennessee to respond to the petition by November 12. Rehearing en banc is rarely granted, and calling for a response does not mean it will be. Because a timely petition holds the mandate, the Tennessee injunction stays in place until the mandate issues.

Changes

October 2026

  • Schedule

    The Sixth Circuit ordered Ohio and Tennessee to respond to Kalshi’s petition for rehearing en banc by November 12, with no extensions. The mandate still has not issued, so the Tennessee injunction remains in place.

    Letter directing responses, 6th Cir. Nos. 26-3196/5235 (Dkt. 95)
  • Filing

    Kalshi asked the full Sixth Circuit to rehear its Ohio and Tennessee loss, and the CFTC filed an amicus brief in the rehearing proceedings on October 16. The mandate has not issued, so the Tennessee injunction remains in place for now.

    Petition for rehearing en banc, 6th Cir. Nos. 26-3196/5235

September 2026

  • Ruling

    The Sixth Circuit ruled for Ohio and Tennessee in a published opinion: Kalshi has not shown its sports contracts are swaps, and even if they were, the CEA would not preempt either state’s gambling law. It affirmed Ohio’s denial and vacated Tennessee’s injunction. The circuits now stand two to one against the platforms.

    Sixth Circuit opinion, Nos. 26-3196/5235

Timeline

January 2026

Kalshi sues Tennessee officials (M.D. Tenn.); Judge Trauger grants a TRO within days.

February 2026

Judge Trauger grants Kalshi a preliminary injunction in Tennessee.

March 2026

S.D. Ohio (Chief Judge Morrison) denies Kalshi a preliminary injunction, creating the intra-circuit split.

April 2026

Sixth Circuit denies a stay of Ohio enforcement but expedites the appeal (No. 26-3196).

July 30, 2026

The Ohio and Tennessee appeals are argued together before Judges Clay, Gibbons and Bloomekatz.

September 25, 2026

The Sixth Circuit affirms the Ohio denial and vacates the Tennessee injunction in a published opinion by Judge Gibbons.

October 9, 2026

Kalshi petitions for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc in both appeals, citing the circuit split and the CFTC’s October 9 rulemakings.

October 16, 2026

The CFTC files an amicus brief in both appeals.

October 28, 2026

The court directs Ohio and Tennessee to respond to the en banc petition by November 12.

November 10, 2026

Tennessee files its response to Kalshi’s petition for rehearing en banc (No. 26-5235); the clerk locks the first filing for being entered in both appeals and tells counsel to refile.

What's next: Kalshi’s petition for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc, filed October 9, 2026, is pending, and the CFTC filed an amicus brief on October 16. In a clerk’s letter dated October 28 the court directed Ohio and Tennessee to respond by November 12, 2026, in no more than 3,900 words, with no extensions. Tennessee filed its response on November 10 (No. 26-5235); the clerk locked the first filing because it had been entered in both appeals and told counsel to refile. Ohio’s response was due November 12; it is not on the free public record as of November 12, and neither is Tennessee’s refiled response. Calling for a response is a required step before the court can grant rehearing en banc, but it does not mean rehearing will be granted. There has been no ruling and no mandate. Under Rule 41(b) of the Federal Rules of Appellate Procedure the mandate waits on the petition, so the Tennessee injunction stays in place until it issues. If rehearing is denied, Kalshi can seek certiorari; no cert petition has been filed. The decision binds the three Michigan platform appeals and the new Underdog and Polymarket US suits against Tennessee and Ohio.

Parties

Plaintiffs

  • KalshiEX LLC

Defendants

  • Matthew T. Schuler (Executive Director, Ohio Casino Control Commission)
  • Dave Yost (Ohio Attorney General)
  • Ohio Casino Control Commission
  • William Orgel (Chair, Tennessee Sports Wagering Council)
  • Jonathan Skrmetti (Tennessee Attorney General)
  • Mary Beth Thomas
This page is informational, not legal advice. Nearly every entry in this tracker is a preliminary ruling under appeal. Always verify a platform's current, location-specific eligibility directly with the venue before relying on this page.