KalshiEX LLC v. Knudsen

Dismissed by stipulation (enforcement standstill)9th Cir.Kalshi v. State

Docket last checked November 12, 2026. Snapshot — not legal advice.

As of November 12, 2026, the legality of prediction markets in Montana is unresolved — litigation is ongoing with no final ruling yet. Montana status and cases →

Overview

After Montana’s Gambling Control Division issued cease-and-desist orders concluding Kalshi’s contracts are illegal gambling under state law, Kalshi sued Attorney General Austin Knudsen and gaming officials (April 2026) for a preliminary injunction on preemption grounds, asserting the state broke a 2025 non-enforcement understanding tied to the Nevada matter. The parties then stayed the case by agreement for months.

On August 27, 2026 Judge Donald W. Molloy refused to extend that stay, lifted it, and denied the injunction without prejudice, reasoning that Kalshi’s repeated agreement to pause the case for months at a time undercut any claim of irreparable harm. Three weeks later the parties settled it. Under a joint stipulation filed September 17 and entered as an order of dismissal on September 21, the case is dismissed with prejudice as to the five Gaming Commission members and without prejudice as to the Attorney General and the Gambling Control Division. In exchange, no defendant will bring or refer any enforcement action over Kalshi’s exchange-traded event contracts until “the later of (i) Kalshi’s request for further review being denied, or (ii) the issuance of an en banc decision,” and after that only on thirty days’ written notice. The agreement was reached in connection with Kalshi’s rehearing petition in Assad, which the Ninth Circuit denied on November 4, 2026. Kalshi has since asked that court to stay its mandate while it seeks Supreme Court review, and the stipulation’s text does not say whether that keeps the standstill running.

Changes

November 2026

  • Correction

    Our entry said Montana’s standstill ended when the Ninth Circuit denied rehearing in Assad on November 4. The stipulation runs until the later of Kalshi’s request for further review being denied or an en banc decision, and its text does not say whether Kalshi’s move toward the Supreme Court extends it. Either way, Montana must give Kalshi thirty days’ written notice before any enforcement.

    Joint stipulation of dismissal, D. Mont. No. 6:26-cv-00028 (Doc. 35, Sept. 17, 2026)

September 2026

  • Ruling

    Kalshi’s Montana case is over: dismissed on a joint stipulation in exchange for Montana’s promise not to enforce until the Ninth Circuit resolves Kalshi’s en banc petition in Assad, then only on thirty days’ notice. We had also missed Judge Molloy’s August 27 denial of the injunction.

    Joint stipulation of dismissal (Doc. 35)

Timeline

April 2026

Kalshi sues AG Knudsen and Montana gaming officials seeking a preliminary injunction (D. Mont., 6:26-cv-00028).

August 27, 2026

Judge Molloy lifts the stay and denies the preliminary injunction without prejudice.

September 17–21, 2026

The parties stipulate to dismissal with an enforcement standstill tied to the Assad en banc process; the court dismisses the case.

November 4, 2026

The Ninth Circuit denies rehearing and rehearing en banc in Assad, the petition the standstill was tied to; Montana must give thirty days’ written notice before any enforcement.

November 9, 2026

Kalshi asks the Ninth Circuit to stay its Assad mandate pending a petition for certiorari; whether that extends the Montana standstill is not settled by the stipulation’s text.

What's next: Closed. The standstill runs until the later of Kalshi’s request for further review being denied or an en banc decision. The Ninth Circuit denied rehearing in Assad on November 4, 2026, and on November 9 Kalshi asked it to stay the mandate pending a petition for certiorari; whether a pending cert petition counts as a “request for further review” under the stipulation is not settled. Either way, Montana must give Kalshi thirty days’ written notice before bringing or referring an enforcement action, and no notice had been reported as of November 12. The dismissal is without prejudice as to the Attorney General and the Gambling Control Division, so the dispute can return.

Parties

Plaintiffs

  • KalshiEX LLC

Defendants

  • Austin Knudsen (Montana Attorney General)
  • Montana gaming officials
This page is informational, not legal advice. Nearly every entry in this tracker is a preliminary ruling under appeal. Always verify a platform's current, location-specific eligibility directly with the venue before relying on this page.