KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad (below: KalshiEX LLC v. Hendrick)

Also captioned KalshiEX, LLC v. Assad; KalshiEX LLC v. Hendrick

Injunction dissolution affirmed (9th Cir., published); rehearing denied; motion to stay the mandate pending9th Cir.Kalshi v. State

Docket last checked November 11, 2026. Snapshot — not legal advice.

As of November 12, 2026, Nevada has a restriction on prediction-market platforms currently in effect. Nevada status and cases →

Overview

Nevada’s federal track, and now the most consequential loss in the industry. Kalshi won a preliminary injunction against Nevada in April 2025, then the same judge dissolved it in November 2025. On August 28, 2026 the Ninth Circuit affirmed that dissolution in a published opinion (R. Nelson, Bade, Lee; opinion by Judge R. Nelson, concurrence by Judge Lee), holding that Kalshi’s sports event contracts are likely not “swaps” under the Commodity Exchange Act because they are sports bets, and that the CEA therefore likely does not preempt Nevada’s gaming laws as applied to them. The panel also declined to defer to the CFTC’s contrary definition of “gaming,” citing Loper Bright.

The opinion quotes Kalshi’s own 2024 brief to the D.C. Circuit back at it — that “the classic example” of gaming “is a contract on the outcome of a sporting event” — and answers: “We agree.” Election contracts were not decided; the panel remanded for the district court to consider Nevada’s challenge to those in the first instance. On November 4, 2026 the panel denied rehearing, and no Ninth Circuit judge asked for an en banc vote.

Read the split precisely. This is not a circuit split about preemption in general — the Ninth Circuit expressly agreed with the Third Circuit in Flaherty that the CEA is a comprehensive scheme that preempts state law regulating futures trading. The disagreement is narrower and more decisive: whether Kalshi’s sports contracts are the kind of instrument the CEA covers at all. Note also the posture — this is abuse-of-discretion review of a preliminary-injunction ruling, not a final merits judgment. It runs alongside the separate state-court geofencing matter.

Changes

November 2026

October 2026

  • Filing

    Kalshi told the Ninth Circuit that the CFTC’s new swap-definition rules support rehearing in Assad, and asked again that the court wait for final rules. The court accepted three amicus briefs on October 13, and the petition remains pending.

    Kalshi’s Rule 28(j) letter, 9th Cir. No. 25-7516 (Dkt. 226)
  • Filing

    Kalshi asked the Ninth Circuit to hold its Assad rehearing petition until the CFTC finalizes its revised Rule 40.11, which the agency expects within two months; Nevada opposed on October 1. The petition is still pending, which keeps the mandate from issuing.

    Nevada's response letter, 9th Cir. No. 25-7516

September 2026

  • Filing

    Kalshi asked the Ninth Circuit to rehear Assad, by the panel or en banc. The petition holds the mandate, so the remand on election contracts and the stayed Arizona appeal both wait on it. Paradigm Operations and the Coalition for Prediction Markets filed amicus briefs in support.

    CourtListener — No. 25-7516 (9th Cir.)

Timeline

April 2025

Kalshi wins a preliminary injunction against Nevada gaming regulators.

November 2025

The same court dissolves the injunction, finding Kalshi unlikely to show its contracts are “swaps.”

November 2025

Kalshi appeals to the Ninth Circuit (No. 25-7516).

April 2026

Argued and submitted in San Francisco before Judges R. Nelson, Bade and Lee.

August 2026

The Ninth Circuit affirms in part and remands in part in a published opinion: sports event contracts are likely not “swaps”; the election-contract question returns to the district court.

September 9, 2026

Kalshi petitions for panel rehearing and rehearing en banc; amicus briefs in support follow from Paradigm Operations and the Coalition for Prediction Markets.

September 24–25, 2026

The district court stays discovery by stipulation; Kalshi asks the Ninth Circuit to hold its rehearing petition until the CFTC’s revised Rule 40.11 is final.

October 1, 2026

Nevada opposes rehearing and any hold.

October 2026

Kalshi cites the CFTC’s new swap-definition rules in support of rehearing; the court accepts three amicus briefs.

November 4, 2026

The panel denies panel rehearing; no judge requests an en banc vote, so rehearing en banc is denied too.

November 9, 2026

Kalshi asks the Ninth Circuit to stay its mandate pending a petition for certiorari.

What's next: The panel (R. Nelson, Bade, Lee) unanimously denied panel rehearing on November 4, 2026, and no judge requested a vote on rehearing en banc. Under the appellate rules the mandate issues seven days after that order unless the court stays it. On November 9, 2026 Kalshi moved to stay the mandate while it petitions the Supreme Court for certiorari (DktEntry 232, captioned KalshiEX LLC v. George Assad et al.); the court has not ruled on the motion in the free public record. A stay would keep the case at the Ninth Circuit; without one, the mandate issues. Under the Supreme Court’s rules Kalshi has 90 days from the denial to petition for certiorari, to about February 2, 2027, unless extended. Once the mandate issues, the election-contract question returns to Judge Gordon, and the appeals held behind this one (Kalshi’s Nevada remand appeal, No. 26-1304; Polymarket’s remand appeal, No. 26-1343; Kalshi’s stayed Arizona appeal, No. 26-2978) can start moving. In the district court, discovery is stayed by stipulation (September 24) for five months or until the Supreme Court acts on the last pending related cert petition, whichever comes first.

Parties

Plaintiffs

  • KalshiEX LLC

Defendants

  • George Assad
  • Nevada Gaming Control Board
  • Nevada Gaming Commission
  • Mike Dreitzer
  • Aaron D. Ford (Nevada Attorney General)
  • Chandeni K. Sendall (Deputy City Attorney)
  • Jennifer Togliatti
  • Rosa Solis-Rainey
  • Brian Krolicki
  • George Markantonis
  • Abbi Silver
  • Nevada Resort Association (intervenor-defendant)
This page is informational, not legal advice. Nearly every entry in this tracker is a preliminary ruling under appeal. Always verify a platform's current, location-specific eligibility directly with the venue before relying on this page.